Opvallend snelle publicatie van een zgn. Spinoza-strijd
U herinnert zich wellicht het blog over de strijd om Philosophical Superheroes die op vrijdag 1 mei aan de Yale University werd uitgevochten: Dan Garber vs Michael Della Rocca
Welnu, hun teksten zullen al (en dat is buitengewoon snel) in het eerstkomende Journal of the History of Philosophy [July 2015 (vol. 53.3) cf.] worden opgenomen in de rubriek
NOTES AND DISCUSSION
Spinoza, Historiography, and the Principle of Sufficient Reason: An Exchange
Superheroes in the History
of Philosophy: Spinoza, Super-Rationalist
Daniel Garber
Interpreting Spinoza: The
Real is the Rational
Michael Della Rocca
Some Additional (But Not
Final) Words
Daniel Garber
Toevoeging
Op 11 juni 2015 werden de vijf [!] video-opname van de workshop op Youtube gebracht. Hieruit wordt ook duidelijk hoe het zo erop kon lijken dat het een wel heel erg snelle publicatie betrof: de voorbereiding van die artikelen was al langer geleden in gang gebracht. Deze bijeenkomst kwam min of meer aan het eind.
Reacties
Op Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog verscheen gisteren dit bericht:
Michael Della Rocca (Yale) writes:
Recently -- in May -- Dan Garber and I had a friendly debate in which we discussed both matters of interpretation of Spinoza and the issue of methodologies for the study of history of philosophy. On the former topic, the focus was on Dan's criticisms of my PSR-based interpretation of Spinoza in my book for the Routledge series. The debate took place at Yale as part of our early modern workshop and was well attended by folks from Princeton as well as from Yale and elsewhere. The event was recorded and it was entitled "Philosophical Superheroes?". (A similar debate recently appeared in the pages of the Journal of the History of Philosophy.)
http://leiterreports.typepad.com/blog/2015/08/philosophical-superheroes-garber-and-della-rocca-in-discussion.html
Stan Verdult 28-08-2015 @ 12:05